Who Was Your First Celebrity Crush? 23 Women Reveal Who First Stole Their Heart

"Although I loved the Backstreet Boys and *NSYNC equally, Justin stole my heart at the ripe age of 9 with his ramen hair and superb taste in sweaters, denim, and tiny sunglasses. I even had the JT marionette doll from the collection after the No Strings Attached album was released. This crush has transcended time and stereotypes and I still think he's fine." — Dominique Astorino, assistant fitness editor