Who Was Your First Celebrity Crush? 23 Women Reveal Who First Stole Their Heart

"I loved his blue eyes, his acting talent, and even his bowl cut (circa The Good Son). I had Bop magazine posters of him all over my room, and I even wrote him fan mail. As a practical joke, my mom once called me pretending to be his mom and told me to stop harassing her son. She thought she was SO funny." — Shannon Vestal Robson, content director