Skip Nav
Love It. Save Your Favorites Now.
22 Cute and Creepy Gifts For American Horror Story Fans

Gifts For American Horror Story Fans

22 Cute and Creepy Gifts For American Horror Story Fans

Gifts For American Horror Story Fans

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

Hoping to get something special for the American Horror Story fan in your life? We have plenty of suggestions! After all, why wait until the holiday season when you can get your pal a Room 64 key now? Apparel and twisted books aren't the only options; there are tons of unexpected gifts like stylish gothic jewelry and snarky t-shirts. Plus, who wouldn't want a Countess figurine for their desk?

Related:
The Butchery on Main T-shirt ($20)

The Butchery on Main T-shirt ($20)

The Butchery on Main T-shirt ($20)
The Butchery on Main T-shirt
$20
from etsy.com
Buy Now
Victoria's Glad-Rocks Ring ($37)

Victoria's Glad-Rocks Ring ($37)

Victoria's Glad-Rocks Ring ($37)
Victoria's Glad-Rocks Ring
$37
from amazon.com
Buy Now
"I am the Supreme" Bracelet ($16)

"I am the Supreme" Bracelet ($16)

"I am the Supreme" Bracelet
"I am the Supreme" Bracelet
$16
from etsy.com
Buy Now
American Horror Story: Hotel DVD ($15)

American Horror Story: Hotel DVD ($15)

American Horror Story: Hotel DVD ($15)
American Horror Story: Hotel DVD
$15
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Freak Show DVD ($13)

Freak Show DVD ($13)

Freak Show DVD ($13)
Freak Show DVD
$13
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Hypodermic Sally Doll ($34)

Hypodermic Sally Doll ($34)

Hypodermic Sally Doll ($34)
Hypodermic Sally Doll
$34
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Gold Skull Earrings ($42)

Gold Skull Earrings ($42)

Gold Skull Earrings ($42)
Gold Skull Earrings
$42
from www1.bloomingdales.com
Buy Now
Victorian Gothic Earrings ($22)

Victorian Gothic Earrings ($22)

Victorian Gothic Earrings ($22)
Victorian Gothic Earrings
$22
from amazon.com
Buy Now
American Horror Story: Asylum on DVD ($14)

American Horror Story: Asylum on DVD ($14)

American Horror Story: Asylum on DVD ($14)
American Horror Story: Asylum on DVD
$14
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Hotel Cortez Room 64 Keychain ($12)

Hotel Cortez Room 64 Keychain ($12)

Hotel Cortez Room 64 Keychain
Hotel Cortez Room 64 Keychain
$12
from etsy.com
Buy Now
American Horror Story: Coven on DVD ($14)

American Horror Story: Coven on DVD ($14)

American Horror Story: Coven on DVD ($14)
American Horror Story: Coven on DVD
$14
from amazon.com
Buy Now
The Countess Pop! Doll ($17)

The Countess Pop! Doll ($17)

The Countess Pop! Doll ($17)
The Countess Pop! Doll
$17
from amazon.com
Buy Now
I'm the Next Supreme Sweatshirt ($21)

I'm the Next Supreme Sweatshirt ($21)

I'm the Next Supreme Sweatshirt ($21)
I'm the Next Supreme Sweatshirt
$21
from etsy.com
Buy Now
Asylum Wooden Wall Hanger ($15)

Asylum Wooden Wall Hanger ($15)

Asylum Wooden Wall Hanger ($15)
Asylum Wooden Wall Hanger
$15
from etsy.com
Buy Now
On Wednesdays We Wear Black T-Shirt ($20)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black T-Shirt ($20)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black T-Shirt ($20)
On Wednesdays We Wear Black T-Shirt
$20
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Cult-inspired soap ($7)

Cult-inspired soap ($7)

Cult-inspired soap ($7)
Cult-inspired soap
$7
from etsy.com
Buy Now
"Balenciaga" Hoop Wall Hanging ($42)

"Balenciaga" Hoop Wall Hanging ($42)

"Balenciaga" Hoop Wall Hanging ($42)
"Balenciaga" Hoop Wall Hanging
$42
from etsy.com
Buy Now
American Horror Story: Season 1 on DVD ($10)

American Horror Story: Season 1 on DVD ($10)

American Horror Story: Season 1 on DVD ($10)
American Horror Story: Season 1 on DVD
$10
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Roanoke Speak Pig T-Shirt ($10)

Roanoke Speak Pig T-Shirt ($10)

Roanoke Speak Pig T-Shirt ($10)
Roanoke Speak Pig T-Shirt
$10
from hottopic.com
Buy Now
On Wednesdays We Wear Black Mug ($10)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black Mug ($10)

On Wednesdays We Wear Black Mug ($10)
On Wednesdays We Wear Black Mug
$10
from hottopic.com
Buy Now
Roanoke The Blood Moon Is Coming Necklace ($10)

Roanoke The Blood Moon Is Coming Necklace ($10)

Roanoke The Blood Moon Is Coming Necklace ($10)
Roanoke The Blood Moon Is Coming Necklace
$10
from hottopic.com
Buy Now
The World Is Wrong Beanie ($12)

The World Is Wrong Beanie ($12)

The World Is Wrong Beanie ($12)
The World Is Wrong Beanie
$12
from hottopic.com
Buy Now
Best Father's Day Gifts at Tecovas
Father's Day
10 Father’s Day Gifts at Tecovas, From Bestselling Boots to Elevated Basics
by Adelaide Giesey 3 weeks ago
Off Campus Popsugar Pulse Cover: Shop the Outfits
TV
Shop the Date-Ready Looks From Our "Off Campus" Cover
by Jessica Andrews 5/13
Rob Rausch Answers Our Biggest Traitors Questions
TV
Rob Rausch Knows You Want the "Traitors" Tea
by Chandler Plante 2/02
The Best Valentine's Day Gifts For Him and Her
Valentine's Day
The Best Valentine’s Day Gifts, From "Heated Rivalry" Finds to Hailey Bieber Lingerie
by Haley Lyndes 2/04
What Underwear Do Shane and Ilya Wear in Heated Rivalry?
UNIQLO
We Found the "Heated Rivalry" Underwear Worn by Shane and Ilya — and It's $15
by Sarah Wasilak 1/16
I Went to Macy's Holiday Square Editor's Outpost
Holiday
I Crafted My Very Own Scent at Macy's Holiday Square, and I'm Obsessed
by Shari Straker 12/23/25

Now You Know

Love Is Blind: Where Do Those Engagement Rings Come From?

Fashion

Everything to Know About the "Love Is Blind" Engagement Rings

by Sarah Wasilak 2/19

shopping

Oprah's Favorite Things List Has Major Gems, Including an Under-$100 Air Fryer

by Balim Tezel 11/06/25

Fitness

Paralympians Earn the Same Pay For Medals as Olympians, but Is It Enough?

by Karenna Meredith 8/29/24

health

How Often Should We Be Getting COVID Vaccines?

by Alexis Jones 8/23/24

Latest Entertainment
We're Hiring! Write For Us Advertise With Us Accessibility Contact Archives
Power Your Happy
Terms Privacy Policy
©2026 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.