Glee ended two years ago, but the cast is still as close as ever. Lea Michele and Darren Criss, who played Rachel and Blaine on the hit singing drama, recently teamed up to promote their new music and gave us a heavy dose of nostalgia in the process. During a Facebook Live video, the two re-created their very first duet together on the show, "Don't You Want Me," from season two, episode 14, when the New Directions got drunk at Rachel's house party. In honor of their drunken duet, the two toasted with a glass of wine before stepping back into their famous roles. And that's what you missed on Glee! You can also check out the original performance below to see how it compares.