Popsugar Entertainment American Horror Story American Horror Story Halloween Costumes Every American Horror Story Character You Could Be For Halloween October 25, 2020 by Maggie Panos View On One Page Photo 46 of 93 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 46 Monsignor Timothy Howard, Asylum What to wear: A black priest's uniform shouldn't be hard to find; just make sure you take a rosary along with you. How to act: Use a British accent, and ask if anyone has seen Sister Jude. Previous Next Start Slideshow American Horror StoryHalloweenHalloween CostumesPop Culture Halloween CostumesTVAmerican Horror Story HotelHalloween Costumes 2020