Popsugar Entertainment American Horror Story Who Has Died on American Horror Story: Freak Show All of American Horror Story: Freak Show's Gruesome Fatalities January 23, 2015 by Maggie Panos View On One Page Photo 26 of 33 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 26 Paul the Illustrated Seal Paul is the first victim of Dandy's killing spree. Dandy walks right up to him and shoots him point-blank in the head. Previous Next Start Slideshow American Horror StoryTVAmerican Horror Story Freak Show