14 Characters Who Could Totally Have Been "A" on Pretty Little Liars

Why We Thought She Was "A":

• Lesli's only been in a handful of episodes, but she's already proving to be pretty shady. She even lies under oath!
• We know Lesli has spent time in Radley Sanitarium, which means, not only is she shady, but she's not totally mentally sound.
• Remember when Mona fails to retrieve Lesli's Radley records, and Lesli gets super pissed off? Why would she care so much unless she has more to hide?
• She clearly doesn't really like any of the girls, which would align pretty well with the continued vendetta "A" seems to have against them.

Why We Figured She Wasn't "A":

• Lesli is pretty new to the whole scene, and we have a feeling we'd have seen traces of her before in order to make the "A" reveal more impactful.
• "A" is like, a mastermind, and if there were incriminating records out there, they'd never see the light of day. "A" would have them in a second.
• Mona really seems to trust Lesli, and that's really saying something. Mona doesn't just trust people willy-nilly.