Pretty Little Liars: A Timeline of the Night Ali Disappears

Alison meets Ian at the Kissing Rock.

• They banter back and forth, and Alison is obviously still smarting from what happened at Hilton Head.
• This doesn't stop them from making out a little, and the vibe turns playful when she pretends to die in front of the camera.
• This little bit of video causes a lot of confusion for the liars. But when the extended version comes out, it's obvious that Ian didn't kill Alison at that time.
• What it does prove is that Alison and Ian have a very toxic, dysfunctional relationship — going from threats to kisses to morbid pranks.