Who Is It This Time? 8 Pretty Little Liars Girls Who Could Be the New Red Coat

Why She's Red Coat:

• Oh, Paige. Paige is allegedly in California, but haven't heard so much as a peep from her since she disappeared. Seems pretty shifty, since she was so involved in the Liars' lives before.
• Paige hates Ali. Remember how Ali used to call her "Pigskin"? Remember how Paige tried to drown Emily? We have a feeling Paige isn't as innocent as she looks.
• She has a knack for sticking her nose where it doesn't belong. Remember how she leaves a note for the police, telling them that Ali is alive and where they can find her? Like, come on!

Why She's Not Red Coat:

• You know, we have to say: we really do believe Paige loves Emily, regardless of what they've been through together. We just can't imagine Paige participating in a huge scheme that would result in Emily's harm.
• If Paige moved away, there's a chance she's just gone. People move on. People fall out of touch. Sh*t happens.