Who Is It This Time? 8 Pretty Little Liars Girls Who Could Be the New Red Coat

Why She's Red Coat:

• OMG, wouldn't this be so juicy? We never see Maya's body. We don't know for sure she's dead. And we do know that she plays into this whole thing more than we're aware of.
• Bianca Lawson, the actress who plays Maya, has not shut down the possibility of Maya's return. In fact, she almost hinted at it: "You never know. Maybe."
• Everyone thinks Maya's dead. If that doesn't clear your schedule for plenty of shenanigans, we don't know what does.

Why She's Not Red Coat:

• Well, let's be real. There's a very good chance Maya is actually dead. Sorry, guys.
• Also, we really do think Maya and Emily cared about each other a lot. Why would Maya go behind Emily's back and betray her like that?
• Also, we can't really figure out what Maya's motive would be. She kind of comes into the show once everything is already in motion. But who knows for sure, right?