16 Times The Vampire Diaries Shocked Our Socks Off

That first time is just a fake-out, thank goodness (take that, Klaus!). But that second death actually takes (well, for a while), and we'll admit there were some legit tears shed. Of course Bonnie dies saving somebody else, because how else could the world's most selfless witch meet her demise, besides saving her best friend's brother and true love, Jeremy?