The Most Bizarre American Horror Story Theories Out There

This is a juicy one. Redditor LambicLifeBlood thinks that Jessica Lange's characters Elsa and Jude are related based on a scene with Elsa and Maggie the fortune teller, who "mentions a woman that looks like her, who took away all her fame. It seems she’s talking about Marlene Dietrich or maybe she’s talking about a twin sister, Sister Jude?”

This could also account for the Pepper's relationship with the two women in the separate universes.