"The Story" by Brandi Carlile
- When it destroyed you: Season seven, episode 18
- Why it destroyed you: The first time "The Story" appears on Grey's Anatomy is in a special season three recap video released by ABC, but the second time is the one we can't help but think of whenever it plays. In the musical episode, Callie is in a coma and Arizona is at her bedside, begging her to wake up. Meanwhile, Callie's spirit witnesses the whole thing go down. Sara Ramirez, who plays Callie, blows the cover out of the water and rips your heart right out.