18 of Your Favorite Horror Movies That Actually Got Terrible Reviews

This 2005 remake has all the trappings of a critical success: Smallville hottie Tom Welling, Lost's Maggie Grace, and a scared-out-of-her-mind Selma Blair. Unfortunately our soft spot for the movie about vengeful ghosts who murderously march out of the fog and into an unsuspecting coastal town wasn't enough to keep reviewers from calling it only "mildly scary."

4 percent