13 Guilty-Pleasure Horror Movies We Can't Help but Love

"Critics may not have loved this 1996 supernatural flick, but I'm borderline obsessed. There are so many great parts of this movie! The chilling 'Light as a Feather, Stiff as a Board' game, Skeet Ulrich (who would go on to play the first baddie of the Scream series) as a sexy high school scoundrel, and don't even get me started on the final sequence with the snakes. It's all pure gold." — Maggie Pehanick, editor