Murderer: Madeline
Victim: Nathan
The Motive: These not-so-friendly exes could take their dislike of each other to the next level. Lots of Madeline's issues have been bubbling up, like her insecurity over her (lack of) career and her insecurity over her ex, Nathan (James Tupper), and his gorgeous wife, Bonnie (Zoe Kravitz). Though Madeline reveals hostility toward Bonnie, especially when she finds out that Bonnie had signed a petition to have her play stopped (described as "a lifeline" for her by another character), it's Nathan she seems to want to take her aggression out on, especially now that Abigail has moved in with Nathan. Complaining to her current husband, Ed (Adam Scott), Madeline whines, "I just thought that one day Nathan would get his due." And maybe that day comes — at Madeline's hand.
