We can't make a Black Hood suspect without mentioning Riverdale's shadiest character, Chic Cooper. Chic has a dark and twisty past, he's murdered before, and it's not hard to see why the inhabitants of the town would be on his sh*t list. Chic also behaves rather strangely the night of the musical. He suspiciously pops up backstage to wish Betty luck, and when Midge's dead body is revealed, he remains eerily calm.
It's also worth noting that the murders stop right around the time Chic moves in with the Coopers. And now that he's out of the house, they've started back up again. On the other hand, Chic is such an obvious suspect. Would they really just wave him in our face like this?!
