Who's Going to Be the Next Bachelor? We (Probably) Know Him Already

With all the controversy surrounding Colton from the start (uh, he dated Becca's friend and former Bachelor contestant Tia Booth), it didn't seem like he would make it that far. But the two were able to move past it, and their relationship was growing in the right direction . . . until, of course, Tia told Becca that she still had feelings for Colton. Now that both of them are going to be on Bachelor in Paradise, we're not sure how likely it is that Colton will become the next Bachelor, but that doesn't mean we won't hold out hope.