28 Early '00s Movies on Netflix That Need to Be on Your Watchlist Immediately

Mamma Mia! meets How I Met Your Mother in this sweet rom-com, which stars Ryan Reynolds as Will, a 30-something dad going through a divorce, and Abigail Breslin as his daughter who wants to know how he and her mother first met. Through flashbacks, Will revisits his past and recounts his relationships with three women, though he leaves his daughter (and the audience) guessing which woman actually became his wife.

Watch it now.