Each Era on Why Women Kill Has a Different Killer and Victim — Here Are Our Picks For Each

Things are getting so tricky because the show is throwing a lot of red herrings at viewers — the opening to episode six when Mary (Analeigh Tipton), Hector (Philip Anthony-Rodriguez), and Lamar (Kevin Daniels) all took turns talking about the death from their respective timelines really threw a wrench in the works.

When Mary said her piece about 1963, she said, "I knew she was going to kill him and I'm so glad she did."

That seems to be implying that Mary's abusive husband Ralph (Scott Porter) is the victim, but we're not so sure anymore. We think after the revelation that Rob is ready to marry April (Sadie Calvano) once Beth Ann dies, Beth Ann is going to snap and kill her husband.