Who the Eff Is Annabelle? 7 Theories About Cruel Summer's Latest Mystery

Talk about being too on the nose! @u/poopyschoopy on Reddit thinks that Annabelle is, at face value, none other than the Annabelle from the Conjuring horror movie franchise. "Maybe he (Martin) dressed as Annabelle or something because he was jealous of Kate and wanted her as like his doll?" While the odds of Cruel Summer entering into a full-fledged Behind Her Eyes–esque paranormal territory are slim to none, I do like the idea.