The Amazon Reboot of I Know What You Did Last Summer Is Almost Nothing Like the Classic Movie

Since the series isn't set in an old fishing town like the original movie, we think it's safe to assume that the killer is not, in fact, a hook-wielding fisherman. Instead, a couple of theories floating around of who the killer may be point to either Dylan, Lennon and Alison's father Bruce (played by Bill Heck), or the mysterious Clara (played by Brooke Bloom), who finds and unveils the victim's body in tact an entire year after the car accident (strange, we know).