Finally: The Definitive Guide to the Best Black Leggings

David Lerner Corset Tie Ankle Leggings ($168)

"More of a 'fashion' pair than a workout pair, these leggings are my favorite for the stylish lace-up waist and petite-friendly fit. As someone who is only 5'1" with a longer torso, it's hard to find high-waisted leggings that cover my belly button and don't need to be hemmed at the bottom. Not only do these sit truly high-waisted on me, but the cropped length also means they fit me like full-length leggings — no tailor necessary." — Stephanie Nguyen, editor, Shopping