M&M's released a new Boo-terscotch (aka butterscotch) flavor exclusively to Target, and Delish reports the white chocolate butterscotch candies taste exactly like Butterbeer. Say what!? We could hardly contain our excitement, but when we finally got a chance to try the M&M's ourselves, we had a different opinion altogether. One taster called them "terror-able," and many agreed the candies tasted artificial and way too sweet. However, there were a few who gave them a near perfect score, so these Halloween morsels might still be for you. If you're really looking to satiate your Butterbeer craving, thankfully we have a Butterbeer recipe made with homemade butterscotch sauce to tide you over.