Skip Nav

Peeps Mystery Flavors 2017

13 of the Weirdest Guesses You Could Imagine For Peeps' Mystery Flavors

Spring is a fun time of year for many reasons, and one is that Peeps releases a new batch of seriously perplexing mystery flavors. Longtime Peeps fans and Peeps haters alike can't help but be lured in by the ambiguous packaging and intriguing scents. As always, there are three mystery flavors this year, and Peeps won't reveal the true flavors until later this season.

All the Peeps are white as to not give away any hints, but each Peep this year is covered in speckles of blue and purple, red and orange, and green and yellow. While we're not sure that the color is any indication of the flavor, it was fun to take the plunge and tear into each Peeps package to speculate our predictions. Ahead, read our best guesses for each of the mystery flavors, and see how the ratings stacked up. Between these and Peeps Oreos, it's already been an eventful Peeps season so far.

Mystery Flavor #1

Our guesses:

  1. Pancakes
  2. French Toast
  3. Maple Syrup

Mystery Flavor #2

Our guesses:

  1. Orange Soda
  2. Passion Fruit
  3. Fruity Tootie
  4. Sour Fruit Punch

Mystery Flavor #3

Our guesses:

  1. Key Lime
  2. Mistake Flavor
  3. Lemon-Lime Candle
  4. Sour Margarita
  5. Lemon
  6. No, Just No

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Erin Cullum
Latest Recipes, Menus, Food & Wine