Spread 'Em Thick: 10 Smears From the Winter Fancy Food Show

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

We're not quite sure what it is, but we flock to spreads like sailors possessed by a siren's song. Which is why we made it a priority to scout new obsession-worthy options at the Winter Fancy Food Show. This year, vendors delivered with everything from a tangy yogurt spread to a crush-worthy graham cracker cookie butter that you need to know.

Photo: Susannah Chen

Hope Spreads Dark Chocolate Chile

Hope Spreads Dark Chocolate Chile

Hope Spreads Dark Chocolate Chile isn't the first time we've seen chickpeas in a sweet form (remember this chickpea cookie dough from POPSUGAR Fitness?), but we can't say we've ever seen a chile chocolate hummus with Indian spices like cardamom, cumin, and cinnamon.

Photo: Anna Monette Roberts

Di Bruno Bros. Abbruzze Cheese Spread

Di Bruno Bros. Abbruzze Cheese Spread

Imagine if pimento cheese took a trip to Italy, and in essence you have Di Bruno Bros. Abbruzze Cheese Spread ($6). Like pimento cheese, it includes red peppers as well as a heavy hit of spice. It diverges from the retro recipe by nixing the mayo and adding a blend of three cheeses, roasted garlic, and Italian herbs to the mix.

Photo: Susannah Chen

Bonelli Simply Sesame Pistachio Cardamom

Bonelli Simply Sesame Pistachio Cardamom

You might not think of spreading tahini on toast or apple slices, but one taste of Bonelli Simply Sesame Pistachio Cardamom may make you reconsider. Here, cardamom's sweet, almost floral flavor tames the sesame's bitterness, and morsels of pistachio add a satisfying crunch.

Photo: Nicole Perry

Woolwich Dairy Cocoa Loco

Woolwich Dairy Cocoa Loco

No, that's not a tub of Nutella, but rather Woolwich Dairy Cocoa Loco, an irresistibly tangy chocolate goat-cheese spread.

Photo: Susannah Chen

Karoun Dairies Blue Isle Mediterranean Yogurt Spread Honey

Karoun Dairies Blue Isle Mediterranean Yogurt Spread Honey

Karoun Dairies debuted its Blue Isle Mediterranean Yogurt Spreads. Of the line, Honey is the can't-miss flavor. The subtly sweet, full-fat yogurt has a spreadable, cream-cheese like consistency but with the probiotic benefits of yogurt. Our bagels have found their new favorite schmear.

Photo: Susannah Chen

Amoretti Graham Cracker Cookie Spread

Amoretti Graham Cracker Cookie Spread

Our latest cookie-butter crush takes inspiration from a beloved childhood snack: graham crackers. A word of caution: like Biscoff and speculoos spreads, buy Amoretti Graham Cracker Cookie Spread at your own risk; it's a little too tempting.

Photo: Nicole Perry

Vermont Creamery's Creamy Goat Cheese

Vermont Creamery's Creamy Goat Cheese

We recently tried Vermont Creamery's Creamy Goat Cheese at the Cheesemonger Invitational and fell instantly in love with its whipped texture. This stuff belongs on toast for breakfast or even dolloped atop any chocolate dessert.

Photo: Susannah Chen

El Marques Olive Butter

El Marques Olive Butter

Though some sketchy hydrogenation may be at play, El Marques Olive Butter takes 100 percent olive oil and transforms it into a spreadable, buttery product. The flavor tastes as you would expect it to, but the real fun is in the melt-in-your-mouth quality.

Photo: Anna Monette Roberts

Karoun Breakfast Cream Spread

Karoun Breakfast Cream Spread

Essentially clotted cream with a touch of tang and a smoother texture, Karoun Breakfast Cream Spread is begging to be slathered on crumpets, scones, and other carby delights.

Photo: Susannah Chen

Skillet Fennel & Black Pepper Bacon Spread

Skillet Fennel & Black Pepper Bacon Spread

If you've tried sweet and salty bacon jam before, you likely need no convincing to snap up a jar of Skillet's latest creation: Skillet Fennel & Black Pepper Bacon Spread ($15). Like its original bacon spread, this variation is tantalizing when spread on crackers, burger buns, and the like, but what sets it apart is its lighter, brighter flavor.

Photo: Nicole Perry