80+ Pumpkin Spice Products, Ranked From Worst to Best

Like an upscale, pumpkin-spiced version of Cow Tales, Williams-Sonoma Pumpkin Pie Caramels ($15) are more fudgey and less chewy in texture than your typical caramel, but we're not complaining. Buttery, not too sweet, and a little spicy, they'll win over nearly anyone with one caveat: they're missing that pop of salinity that salted-caramel-lovers might be looking for.

Photo: Anna Monette Roberts