11 December Must Haves That'll Get the Party Started

For all you cookie butter fans out there, Gooey on the Inside ($10) just took it to the next level. Not only has it created out-of-this-world flavors like Fluffernana, Honeycomb, Red Velvet, Vanilla Birthday Cake, and Marshmallow Crispie, but they are also hand-crafted, all-natural, and preservative-free. These cookie butters taste exactly like their baked counterparts and are loaded with delicious add-ins like white chocolate, real pieces of birthday cake, shortbread, and honeycomb clusters. They're tasty on bread, fruit, ice cream, crackers, and cookies or, my personal favorite, straight off a spoon.

— Brandi Milloy, host/producer