Updated! Pick This Up, Not That: Trader Joe's New September Foods

Apples and cheddar is a classic (though somewhat puzzling) flavor combination, which inspired this new Apple Pie Cheddar Cheese. Made with actual apple cider and spices you'd find in apple pie, like cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, this sharp white cheddar cheese has a sweet bite to it that cuts through the saltiness. Many of our tasters shook their heads in confusion upon biting into this, and the overall consensus is we wouldn't buy it or cook with it. Unless you're a die-hard fan of cheddar and apples, skip out on this one.