Pick This Up, Not That: Trader Joe's New October Foods

Don't let the striking orange color of this cheese scare you away — it's naturally colored from a generous amount of paprika. Trader Joe's Buenabla Cheese With Paprika is a hybrid of goat cheese and sheep's milk cheese, so it's salty, tangy, and right in between a hard and soft cheese. The fragrant paprika doesn't just coat the outside, but it's mixed into the cheese entirely, giving you a slightly smoky, sweet kick with every bite.