Introduced in 2014, Pumpkin Spice Oreos were quite the polarizing flavor among Oreo fans. Pumpkin-spice-flavored foods tend to create two distinct sides: love or hate. Surprisingly, after biting into the buttery cookies for ourselves, our editors were delighted. They're not all that pumpkiny, and the orange creme filling has plenty of cinnamon. Far better than plenty other pumpkin spice products out there, we'd undoubtedly pick these up every Fall.