POPSUGAR Editors' Definitive Ranking of the 15 Weirdest Oreo Flavors

S'mores Oreos — or S'mOreos, rather — sound so promising but fall flat. While you'd expect a marshmallow fluff type of filling, the white icing is sadly almost identical to the regular stuff. It's hard to distinguish these from a regular vanilla Oreo with chocolate frosting, and we're left wanting more! If your s'mores craving hits, we recommend making the real thing.