The Definitive Ranking of Peanut Butter Candy

Butterfinger is probably one of the most polarizing candies — people either love it or hate it. Although I'm personally a Butterfinger enthusiast, even I understand it belongs toward the bottom of the list of the best peanut butter candies, by pure comparison. It crumbles everywhere and is much more difficult to eat than its competitors whose fillings are much softer and creamier.