Jeni's Splendid Has New State-Fair-Themed Ice Creams, and OMG, the Watermelon Taffy

I was afraid this one would taste weird. Popcorn in an ice cream? I don't know about that. But the popcorn flavor is pretty subtle and complements the creaminess of the ice cream. It definitely tastes of popcorn, but it's not too buttery. This is a great option for when you're craving popcorn but want something cold instead.