If You Only Buy 1 Yankee Candle Halloween Scent This Year, Make Sure It's This One

Yankee Candle "Forbidden Apple" ($20) with notes of red delicious apple, bergamot, black oak, and vanilla noir.

We gave it:

Editors said:

• "VERY apple-y; I feel like it would smell better when lit."
• "Not bad, but also not very Halloween to me."
• "Like Herbal Essences."
• "I like this! But agree it isn't particularly Halloweeny."
• "Doesn't really remind me of Halloween. More like apple shampoo?"