Buffy Supima Cotton Sheet Set ($128, originally $150)
"Buffy's Supima Cotton Sheet Set appears to be a standard, no-frills situation at first glance — almost like what you'd expect to see in a hotel room — but after a full night's sleep, the difference is clear. The Supima cotton is comparably softer to the touch than any of my other sheets, and it has a crisp, cooling effect overnight. I often sweat in my sleep as a side effect of my anxiety medication, but I wake up perfectly dry with these sheets.
Some details I appreciate are the inner flap on the pillowcase and the head/foot tag on the fitted sheet, which helps you align it seamlessly with your mattress. However, I do have an extremely deep, multi-layered mattress, so I always look for stirrup straps on all four corners as an added bonus to keep everything in place. Since these sheets don't have that feature, I opted to purchase the king-size set (even though my mattress is technically a queen), and I was pleasantly surprised by the fit. If anything, there's just a bit of excess fabric along the sides to account for the different dimensions, but the sheets are absolutely deep enough to encompass all four mattress corners." — Sarah Wasilak, associate director, shop
