The Bachelorette, Jillian Harris
Jillian may have picked Ed in the end, but their fantasy date didn't quite go as planned — and gave Ed an unfortunate nickname of E.D. After lathering each other up with oil in bed, Ed couldn't seal the deal. He said, "I was very nervous, and it didn't just happen. I couldn't show her I really truly was in love with her." Yikes!