Kaitlyn's Most Loved, Hated, and Bizarre Bachelors

Cupcake expressed all the feels when Kaitlyn sent him home, and we can't fault him for it — or entirely disagree with his assessment of Kaitlyn as "a mess" (even though we kind of love her for it). Maybe Kaitlyn did make a huge mistake by letting Cupcake go, so you know what? I'll be mourning their future right along with him.