15 White Elephant Gifts Under $50 That Are Anything but Ordinary

We're Not Really Strangers Card Game ($25)

This game — a deck of questions to help people really get to know each other — is the fast track to deeper conversations, and it's a great tool for anyone to have in their party arsenal. Guaranteed, someone in your white elephant has been wanting to buy it and will do whatever it takes to bring this gift home. Read more in this We're Not Really Strangers Card Game review.

Editor Quote: "Since the answer to the questions will likely change over time, you'll never get bored of playing the game. Consider it a long-term investment into your social or love life." - Shelcy Joseph, former associate editor, Fashion