I Take Gifting Very Seriously — Here Are My Favorite Gifts For Party Hosts

Little Pie Company Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie ($63)

Little Pie Company makes some of the best pies ever — and it's not just me, Rachael Ray also says so — but the bakery only has a location in NYC. Luckily, its famous Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is available on Goldbelly, and I've shipped several to some very pleased non-New Yorkers in the past. You can ship these ahead of your gathering to take something off the host's plate or afterward as a thank-you. If your host isn't a pie person, Goldbelly also offers a huge variety of gourmet food gifts from iconic brands.