Don't Miss These 37 Amazon Cyber Monday Deals Even Our Editors Love

Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream ($26, originally $39)

It doesn't get much more classic than Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream. It's free of fragrance, alcohol, and essential oils, so irritation shouldn't be an issue. Shoppers rave about how well it hydrates and softens their skin with its lightweight, non-greasy texture. Plus, according to multiple reviewers, it wears beautifully under makeup.