I Put 10 Mascaras to the Nap Test So That You Don't Have To

I love the extreme lash-extending quality of this mascara ($24), but I probably wouldn't snooze in it again. While my flutter looked absolutely incredible before passing out, there were flakes left on my pillow and a bit of residue under my eyes after resting. My takeaway? Set this ultralengthening formula aside for a stunning Saturday night-out smoky eye!

My nap-test rating:

Overall rating: