Will You Accept This Contouring Brush? 6 Makeup Secrets From the Bachelor Girls

"I'm into something that looks natural," Moldavon said. Her favorite tool for this is Anastasia's Brow Wiz ($21), but for a more budget version of this product, she recommends BH Cosmetics's Studio Pro HD Brow Pencil ($7).

Moldavon stresses to draw your borders first on the top and bottom and fill it in as you go, spoolie-ing, which is one of the most important steps. "Most people underfill them . . . most people take a product and draw through the middle," she explained. "You have so much real estate there that you have to take advantage of it."