I Tried 12 Eyebrow Pencils to See Which Is the Best For Coarse Brows

I definitely didn't expect this pencil ($20) to be so effective with such a fine tip, but boy, was I wrong. Because the product itself is so thin, I had a ton of control over the way I filled in my brows. Using the Warm Brown shade, I stenciled in the shape of my brow and then filled in with the same fine tip. The formula is smooth and nourishing and blends perfectly. Although I finished off with a gel product, as I've done with all the pencils I've tested, my brows looked equally as strong and defined with the Brow Beater alone.