These 15 Top-Rated Mascaras Are Amazon Bestsellers for a Reason

CoverGirl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara ($9, originally $13)

If you want a "my lashes but better" look, this mascara is a clean version of CoverGirl's beloved Lash Blast mascara. The long-lasting formula is both smudge and clump-proof, and the applicator gives your lashes lift and volume for a feathery look.

Customer review: "This mascara is a game changer! It lifts your lashes without making them look clumpy and crimped. It makes for soft lashes that hold a curl and do not feel heavy all day long. I didn't have any smudging at the end of the day either. One thing I am happy to say, is that I didn't have to rub the eye makeup remover to get this mascara to come off! I don't lose a bunch of lashes afterwards, either."