11 Budge-Proof Eyeliners You Can Pick Up at the Drugstore

Every editorial product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission.

We've all had days where eyeliner has been the bane of our makeup existence. Whether you're a liner rookie or a cat-eye pro, picking the perfect liner can be a challenge. After sorting through various formulas, colors, and finishes, how do you know which liner is best? We've tested and selected these stellar yet budget-friendly liners that rival their high-end counterparts.

01
E.L.F. Intense H20 Proof Eyeliner Pen

E.L.F. Intense H20 Proof Eyeliner Pen

Smudges be gone with this H2O-proof ($6) liner! The pen applicator is makes this liquid liner a breeze to apply.

02
Maybelline Lasting Drama Light Eyeliner

Maybelline Lasting Drama Light Eyeliner

The Lasting Drama Light ($6) brightens and illuminates eyes with a hint of shimmer.

03
Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous

Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous

Stroke of Gorgeous ($5) pencils come in four finishes: Creamy Matte, Chrome, High Intensity Brights, and Glitter. Each finish glides on oh so smoothly.

04
Wet N Wild MegaSlim Skinny Tip Eyeliner

Wet N Wild MegaSlim Skinny Tip Eyeliner

No-makeup makeup days just got easier with this MegaSlim Skinny Tip Liner ($5).

05
Pixi Eye Define Waterline

Pixi Eye Define Waterline

The ultraslim tip on the Eye Define Waterline ($14) is the answer to defined liner sans the tears.

06
Flower Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel

Flower Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel

If you prefer a liner with sheen, the Vinyl-Eyes Glossy Gel ($8) is for you. Its high-shine finish adds boldness to even the simplest of looks.

07
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Matte Lacquer Cream

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Matte Lacquer Cream

There's so much to love in the Eye Booster Matte Lacquer Cream Eyeliner ($8). The twist pen applicator makes perfecting gel liner a breeze and the matte finish adds a subtle edge to any look.

08
Soap & Glory Supercat Skinny Precision Eyeliner

Soap & Glory Supercat Skinny Precision Eyeliner

Create uberthin lines with this Supercat Skinny Precision Eyeliner ($10). Use it to rim your cat eye or create a barely there look.

09
Revlon ColorStay Exactify Liquid Liner

Revlon ColorStay Exactify Liquid Liner

If liquid liner seems nigh impossible for you, this wheel-tip applicator was made for you! The ColorStay Exactify Liquid ($12) allows for precise lines, even with a shaky hand.

10
CoverGirl truNAKED Waterproof Eyeliner Duo

CoverGirl truNAKED Waterproof Eyeliner Duo

The truNAKED Waterproof ($5) duos feature a dual tip to create blended color looks in a breeze.

11
NYX Put a Wing on It

NYX Put a Wing on It

When you want to go there with your liner, Put a Wing on It ($10) marker-like felt tip liner creates bold, graphic lines in a pinch.

12