PSA: Copper Is the New Black When It Comes to Smoky Eyes This Fall

"To get this unique, metal finish, I would use two to three different shades of copper so there's dimension," said Garland. "I love to use pigmented eyeshadows so you can blend out the colors without any fading."

For some copper and gold shades that are next-level gorgeous, try the Makeup by Mario Master Metals Eyeshadow Palette ($48). You can apply the shadows with your finger or use a mixing medium to create a liquid-foil finish.