6 Ultra-Fine Longwear Liners That Refuse To Budge

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner ($10)

An affordable liner with true staying power, I'd venture a guess that over half of my bag collection has a classic black Revlon pencil hidden away in its depths — I'm that loyal to this formula. This liner is one of my favorites for the waterline for both the longwear and the depth of color, especially when you're a stickler for your black liners to, you know, actually look black and not gray on your skin.