4 Editors Put the New Keys Soulcare It's Like Skin Tint to the Test

Keys Soulcare It's Like Skin 2-In-1 Concealer + Tint ($28) in shade 420w

"I love a dewy finish but as someone with acne-prone skin, I also want coverage in my base makeup. It's not often that those two worlds come together in a formula as lightweight as the Keys Soulcare 2-in-1 Skin Tint, but the brand has somehow managed to do it. It doesn't feel heavy on the skin but still offers really incredible medium coverage. It covered my hyperpigmentation like a dream, and smaller texture bumps looked significantly more blurred. However, I will say that due to how hydrating it is, I do fear that it may emphasize any raised pimples on my face, like whiteheads.

Though the brand has 40 shades, I found myself between two, 420 w and 410 n. Neither matched the undertones in my skin perfectly, so I'd I have to do a little extra work with my concealers and powders to get a truly seamless finish." — Ariel Baker, assistant beauty editor

Rating: