During an interview with NYMag's The Cut six months later, Mariah threw subtle shade at Jennifer when asked about the craziest present she's received from a fan recently. After yawning and saying she was having a "sleep moment," the singer said, "Well, there was a very interesting shirt that a fan made with a quote that I said years ago that, when I said it, I really wasn't trying to be funny. I was just being honest and everybody's kind of blowing it out of proportion but this guy had a shirt on and it was a picture of me that he made and the quote was underneath it — and I'm going to leave you hanging as to what it was."
The editor then did her research and discovered that the t-shirt in question was a in fact a fan-made shirt with the words "I Don't Know Her" written across it, obviously referencing the star's previous quote about Jennifer.
